Getting accepted into more than one US college is exciting, but figuring out which is the best fit can feel overwhelming, especially if you’re an international student. Every college has its own academic strengths, campus culture, and support system, and those differences can strongly influence your decision.
The college you choose can shape your experience and future opportunities, so it’s crucial to weigh your options carefully. That’s why we at Remitly created this step-by-step guide to help you decide between two college acceptances and make a confident, informed decision.
This guide breaks down the factors to consider when choosing between colleges, from comparing academic programs to breaking down the costs, and creating a decision matrix.
Step one: Compare academic programs
The first step to attending college is getting accepted. That’s a huge win to start. Now, to make an informed decision, compare college offers by looking closely at the academic programs each school offers for your intended major. A strong program usually has experienced professors, interesting courses, and extras like special tracks, labs, or certificate programs to help you explore your field more deeply.
If you haven’t decided on your major yet, check which college allows you to apply as undecided, giving you more time to explore various subjects before choosing a path.
Internship and hands-on experience
When deciding between colleges, consider how each school supports real-world experience. Gaining hands-on skills during college can give you an edge after graduation.
Some schools actively help students find internships with local businesses, non-profit organizations, or research labs. These programs add value to your college experience and help you build a stronger resume.
Academic support and career prep
Don’t overlook support services. Good academic advising, tutoring, and career centers can help you stay on track for the future. Before deciding on a college, check if they offer services like resume workshops, internship support, and one-on-one coaching. These resources can help better prepare you for life after graduation.
Step two: Break down the cost
After considering academics, take time to compare college offers financially. Look beyond the tuition. Consider the full cost of attendance, which includes housing, transportation, books, supplies, and other daily expenses. Some schools might look cheaper on paper, but cost more when you factor in all the extras.
Review scholarships, grants, and work-study options
Take a close look at what each school is offering in financial aid. Grants and scholarships are funds you don’t have to repay. Work-study provides part-time jobs that can help cover costs.
Some schools might offer better deals or scholarships based on your background, major, or achievements, so be sure to compare them side by side when choosing between colleges.
Consider the long-term impact of loans or part-time work
Think about how much you might need to borrow and how that debt could impact your life after graduation. Federal student loans usually offer better terms than private alternatives. If you plan to work during school, consider how that might affect your study time and well-being.
Ideally, choose a college where you can graduate with minimal debt and a manageable workload. There’s no perfect number, but understanding your future payments and making smart financial moves now can help you avoid stress later.
Step three: Consider campus life and support
College is where you’ll live, make friends, and grow for the next few years. The right environment can shape your comfort, growth, and experience.
Urban campuses are usually in the heart of big cities. You may experience lots of cultural events, diverse communities, and internship opportunities. If you love exploring museums, concerts, or city life, this might be a great fit. Just keep in mind that city life can be expensive and a bit more fast-paced.
Suburban campuses sit in quieter areas, often near major cities. You may experience a peaceful campus vibe with the option to head into town for fun, shopping, or work experience. It’s a nice middle ground.
Rural campuses are often in small towns or countryside settings. These schools usually have tight-knit communities, and you’re more likely to get to know your professors personally. It’s great for focus and connection, but there may be fewer off-campus options for events or entertainment.
Support for first-gen, ESL, and international students
You also need to check the support system each school offers. At most colleges, you’ll get an academic advisor who can help you stay organized with your classes and graduation goals while offering study support. Professors usually have office hours where you can ask questions or get feedback, which can be really helpful when adjusting to a new academic system.
Writing centers and ESL support
Many colleges offer writing centers with tutors who can help with grammar, structure, and citation. These are great for building confidence with academic writing, especially if English isn’t your first language.
Conversation clubs and language partners
Some colleges offer casual clubs or partner programs where international students can practice English with native speakers. These meetups are a fun way to improve your language skills and make friends.
Cultural and wellness centers
Student unions, multicultural centers, and wellness offices host social events, support groups, and workshops. Whether you need help adjusting, managing stress, or building community, these spaces are great resources, especially for international and first-gen students.
Step four: Factor in location and distance from home
Think about how far each college is from your home and how that affects your ability to visit. If one school is a short drive away while the other requires flight or long bus rides, travel costs and convenience become crucial for budgeting.
Being closer to home can provide extra support during tough times, while a college far away may offer more independence, but it comes with added costs and planning.
Weather, culture, and timezone
Do you like warm weather or cooler seasons? If you struggle with extreme cold or heat, factor that into your decision. US time zones and local cultures can also affect your comfort level, especially if you’re a first-generation student from another country. Adapting to a new lifestyle, social habits, or even local food can take time and may impact your overall college experience.
Step five: Trust your gut, but get input too
If possible, make travel arrangements to visit both campuses. After your visit, think about how each made you feel before deciding.
Did you feel comfortable or excited while there? First impressions matter. Sometimes, the best choice isn’t about ranking or stats, it’s about where you can truly see yourself thriving.
Talk to students, mentors, or advisors
Reach out to current students, recent graduates, or trusted mentors to get real insights into daily life at each school. They may share details about academics, support for ESL or first-gen students, campus culture, and things you may not find in brochures.
Hearing different perspectives can either confirm your feelings or raise new points to think about. This can help you make a confident and well-informed decision.
Step six: Create a decision matrix
Start by creating a list of what matters to you. These might include academic programs, tuition and financial aid, campus culture, location, and support services.
Then, think about what you value most in your college experience and assign a score to each category based on its importance to your goals.
Score and compare
Next, rate each college on these categories using a consistent scale—give them each a ranking from one to five in that category, for example. Multiply each score by the number you assigned. Add up the totals to get an overall score for each college.
While numbers can help clarify your thoughts, remember: the highest score isn’t always the automatic winner. Your gut feeling, campus visit impressions, and personal goals are essential factors to consider when deciding on a college.
Final thoughts
There’s no such thing as a perfect college, only the ones that fit your goals, needs, and lifestyle best at this stage of your life. If you’re wondering how to decide between two college acceptances, consider what matters most to you.
Whether it’s academics, financial aid, campus culture, or support as a first-gen or international student, the right choice is the one that helps you grow with confidence.
Take a breath, use these college decision-making tips to weigh your options, and choose the school where you can grow and feel supported. You’ve already done the hard part by getting in.
FAQs
What if I choose the wrong college?
If your college experience isn’t what you expected, you’re not stuck. Many students transfer schools after a semester or a year. Before transferring, try to identify what’s missing and whether those needs can be met where you are. Talk to an academic advisor and explore your options before making a final decision.
Can I switch my decision later?
Once you commit and submit a deposit, switching can be difficult, but not impossible. If circumstances change, contact the admissions office at each school quickly. Act fast and communicate clearly, some schools have waitlists or late openings. Keep in mind that spots and aid may not be guaranteed.
Should I go where I get more aid or where I feel more at home?
Try to balance both. Feeling comfortable is crucial for your mental health and success, but financial health can also take a toll. Compare long-term costs and ask if your top-choice school can match aid offers. Talk to financial aid officers; they may offer additional options you didn’t know about.
What if my family wants one thing and I want another?
It’s okay to want different things. Have an honest conversation with your family about your goals and values. Try to find a common ground, but remember that this is your education and your future. Involving a counselor and a trusted adult can help bridge the conversation if it’s tough.
What if I’m undecided on a major, does that change my choice?
Yes, it can. If you’re still undecided, choose colleges with strong academic advising, flexible general education programs, and a wide range of majors to explore. This gives you room to grow. Look for schools that let you explore during your first year without pressuring you to choose a major right away.
Can I defer my admission and decide later?
Some colleges allow you to defer for a year, but you’ll need to ask for approval and explain your reasons. Always confirm the school’s deferral policy and deadlines. Be sure to get your deferral details in writing so you don’t lose your spot or aid.